16 KiB
phase, verified, status, score, re_verification
| phase | verified | status | score | re_verification |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 02-vault-core-and-rendering | 2026-02-28T21:45:00Z | passed | 17/17 must-haves verified | false |
Phase 2: Vault Core and Rendering Verification Report
Phase Goal: Users can read a markdown document — all standard constructs render correctly and content is scrollable Verified: 2026-02-28T21:45:00Z Status: PASSED Re-verification: No — initial verification
Goal Achievement
Observable Truths
The 17 must-have truths are drawn directly from the three plan frontmatter must_haves sections.
Plan 02-01 Truths (Foundation)
| # | Truth | Status | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | pulldown-cmark, syntect, and syntect-tui compile without errors alongside existing ratatui 0.30 | VERIFIED | cargo build succeeds with 1 pre-existing warning (signals.rs dead_code), zero errors; Cargo.toml has all three dependencies at specified versions |
| 2 | vault.rs can load a markdown file from a vault path and return structured success/missing/error states | VERIFIED | load_document() uses std::fs::read_to_string, matches on ErrorKind::NotFound for Missing, all other errors to ReadError, success to Loaded |
| 3 | highlighter.rs initializes syntect once and can highlight a code string into Vec<Line<'static>> with CGA 16-color palette | VERIFIED | OnceLock<SyntaxSet> and OnceLock<ThemeSet> statics; highlight_code() returns Vec<Line<'static>> with all-owned Span strings; full 16-entry CGA palette in syntect_color_to_cga() |
Plan 02-02 Truths (Renderer)
| # | Truth | Status | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4 | Headings H1-H6 render with distinct CGA colors and decorators (H1=LightCyan+══, H2=LightYellow+──, H3-H6 color-only) | VERIFIED | start_heading() assigns correct CGA colors per level; end_heading() emits ═.repeat(w) for H1, ─.repeat(w) for H2, nothing for H3-H6 |
| 5 | Bold text uses Modifier::BOLD, italic uses Modifier::ITALIC, inline code uses LightCyan styling | VERIFIED | Tag::Strong pushes Modifier::BOLD, Tag::Emphasis pushes Modifier::ITALIC, Event::Code emits Style::default().fg(Color::LightCyan) span |
| 6 | Fenced code blocks render with rounded box-drawing borders (╭─╮│╰─╯) and syntax-highlighted content via highlighter.rs | VERIFIED | emit_code_block() at line 439 uses ╭, │, ╰, ╮, ╯; calls crate::highlighter::highlight_code(code_buf, lang) at line 445 |
| 7 | Ordered and unordered lists render with bullets/numbers and proper indentation per nesting depth | VERIFIED | list_counters: Vec<Option<u64>> tracks nesting; bullets use •/◦/▪ per depth level; ordered lists format {n}. and increment counter |
| 8 | Blockquotes render with a yellow │ left border and gray content | VERIFIED | flush_line() prepends Span::styled("│ ".repeat(depth), Style::default().fg(Color::Yellow)) and re-colors content spans to Color::Gray when in_blockquote |
| 9 | Horizontal rules render as full-width ─── lines in DarkGray | VERIFIED | Event::Rule emits "─".repeat(state.width as usize) styled Color::DarkGray |
| 10 | Images render as [IMAGE: alt text] placeholders in DarkGray+DIM | VERIFIED | End(TagEnd::Image) emits format!("[IMAGE: {}]", alt) with Color::DarkGray and Modifier::DIM |
| 11 | GFM tables render with full box-drawing grid (┌┬┐├┼┤└┴┘) and bold LightCyan header row | VERIFIED | emit_table() uses build_border() with ┌,┬,┐,├,┼,┤,└,┴,┘; header uses Color::LightCyan + Modifier::BOLD |
Plan 02-03 Truths (App Integration)
| # | Truth | Status | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| 12 | App starts and displays index.md content from the configured vault_path | VERIFIED | main.rs calls vault::load_document(&app_config.vault_path, "index.md"), renders via renderer::render_markdown(), passes to App::new() |
| 13 | When index.md is missing, user sees a BBS-style error screen with box-drawing border and helpful message | VERIFIED | draw_error_screen() renders a centered red-bordered Block with "*** SYSTEM ERROR ***" in LightRed+BOLD, path in Yellow, hint in DarkGray |
| 14 | User can scroll content with j/k (one line), arrow keys (one line), PgUp/PgDn (full page) | VERIFIED | handle_key() matches KeyCode::Char('j') | KeyCode::Down, Char('k') | KeyCode::Up, PageDown, PageUp; each calls scroll_down/scroll_up with 1 or page_height() |
| 15 | Status bar at the bottom shows filename on the left and keyboard hints on the right in reverse video | VERIFIED | draw_status_bar() builds left+padding+right Line, renders Paragraph with Style::default().add_modifier(Modifier::REVERSED) |
| 16 | Terminal resize re-renders content at new width and reflows layout without crashing | VERIFIED | Event::Resize(w, _h) triggers handle_resize(w) which calls crate::renderer::render_markdown(content, new_width) and clamps scroll_offset to new max_scroll() |
| 17 | Quit behavior from Phase 1 (q key, double Ctrl+C) is preserved | VERIFIED | handle_key() retains the double Ctrl+C state machine with DOUBLE_PRESS_WINDOW; q key guarded by !self.is_login_shell; show_goodbye() and ShutdownReason unchanged |
Score: 17/17 truths verified
Required Artifacts
| Artifact | Min Lines | Status | Details |
|---|---|---|---|
Cargo.toml |
— | VERIFIED | Contains pulldown-cmark = "0.13.1", syntect = { version = "5.3", default-features = false, features = ["default-fancy"] }, syntect-tui = "3.0" |
src/vault.rs |
— | VERIFIED | VaultDocument enum with Loaded, Missing, ReadError variants; load_document() with std::fs::read_to_string |
src/highlighter.rs |
— | VERIFIED | OnceLock<SyntaxSet>, OnceLock<ThemeSet>; init_highlighter(), syntax_set(), theme_set(), syntect_color_to_cga(), highlight_code(); full 16-entry CGA palette; LinesWithNewlines iterator |
src/renderer.rs |
200 | VERIFIED | 703 lines; render_markdown() public API; RenderState struct; emit_code_block() and emit_table() free functions; handles all Event variants |
src/app.rs |
— | VERIFIED | DocumentState enum; App with Phase 2 fields; draw(), draw_status_bar(), draw_error_screen(), handle_key(), handle_resize(), scroll helpers; all Phase 1 behavior preserved |
src/main.rs |
— | VERIFIED | All 7 mod declarations; highlighter::init_highlighter() before render_markdown(); vault loading with all three match arms; raw_content passed to App::new() |
Key Link Verification
| From | To | Via | Status | Details |
|---|---|---|---|---|
src/highlighter.rs |
syntect | OnceLock<SyntaxSet> and OnceLock<ThemeSet> statics |
WIRED | Lines 10-11: static SYNTAX_SET: OnceLock<SyntaxSet> and static THEME_SET: OnceLock<ThemeSet> |
src/vault.rs |
std::fs |
read_to_string for markdown file loading |
WIRED | Line 31: match std::fs::read_to_string(&full_path) |
src/renderer.rs |
pulldown-cmark | TextMergeStream consuming all Event variants |
WIRED | Line 696: let parser = TextMergeStream::new(Parser::new_ext(input, opts)) |
src/renderer.rs |
src/highlighter.rs |
highlight_code() called for fenced code blocks |
WIRED | Line 445: crate::highlighter::highlight_code(code_buf, lang) |
src/renderer.rs |
ratatui::text | Produces Vec<Line<'static>> with Span styling |
WIRED | Return type of render_markdown() and all emitter functions confirmed Vec<Line<'static>> |
src/main.rs |
src/highlighter.rs |
init_highlighter() called before App::new() |
WIRED | Line 32: highlighter::init_highlighter() at step 3a, before step 7 App::new() |
src/main.rs (via app.rs) |
src/vault.rs |
load_document() called in startup to get markdown content |
WIRED | Line 41: vault::load_document(&app_config.vault_path, "index.md"); result passed as DocumentState to App::new() |
src/app.rs |
src/renderer.rs |
render_markdown() called on resize to re-render at new width |
WIRED | Line 204: crate::renderer::render_markdown(content, new_width) in handle_resize() |
src/app.rs |
ratatui::widgets::Paragraph |
Paragraph::new(lines).scroll((offset, 0)) for scrollable content |
WIRED | Lines 332-334: Paragraph::new(lines.clone()).scroll((self.scroll_offset, 0)) |
Note on plan 02-03 key link app.rs -> vault.rs: The plan specified load_document() called from src/app.rs, but the implementation calls it from src/main.rs and passes the result as DocumentState to App::new(). This is a valid architectural choice — cleaner separation of concerns — and the goal truth ("App starts and displays index.md content") is fully satisfied. The load path is: main.rs -> vault::load_document() -> renderer::render_markdown() -> App::new(DocumentState::Loaded).
Requirements Coverage
| Requirement | Source Plan | Description | Status | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| REND-01 | 02-02 | User sees H1-H6 headers with visual hierarchy and styling | SATISFIED | start_heading() assigns distinct CGA colors per heading level; H1/H2 get decorator lines |
| REND-02 | 02-02 | User sees bold, italic, and inline code rendered with terminal styling | SATISFIED | Modifier::BOLD for Strong, Modifier::ITALIC for Emphasis, Color::LightCyan for inline code |
| REND-03 | 02-01, 02-02 | User sees fenced code blocks with syntax highlighting | SATISFIED | emit_code_block() calls highlight_code() via crate::highlighter; CGA-mapped colors applied |
| REND-04 | 02-02 | User sees ordered and unordered lists with proper indentation | SATISFIED | list_counters vec tracks nesting; •/◦/▪ for unordered; {n}. for ordered; 2-space indent per level |
| REND-05 | 02-02 | User sees blockquotes with visual distinction | SATISFIED | Yellow │ border per nesting depth; content spans re-colored to Color::Gray |
| REND-06 | 02-02 | User sees horizontal rules as visual separators | SATISFIED | Event::Rule emits full-width ─ line in Color::DarkGray followed by blank line |
| REND-07 | 02-02 | User sees [IMAGE: alt text] placeholders for images |
SATISFIED | Image alt text collected, emitted as [IMAGE: {alt}] in Color::DarkGray + Modifier::DIM |
| REND-08 | 02-02 | User sees GFM tables rendered with aligned columns | SATISFIED | emit_table() renders full box-drawing grid; pad_cell() handles Left/Right/Center alignment |
| REND-09 | 02-02 | User sees box-drawing borders on content panels | SATISFIED | Code blocks: ╭─╮│╰─╯ borders; Tables: ┌┬┐├┼┤└┴┘ grid; both use Color::DarkGray/Color::Cyan borders |
| REND-10 | 02-01, 02-02 | User sees CGA-era retro color theme (cyan/magenta/green on dark) | SATISFIED | Full 16-entry CGA palette in syntect_color_to_cga(); heading colors use LightCyan, LightYellow, LightGreen, Green, Cyan, DarkGray |
| NAV-05 | 02-03 | User can scroll content with j/k, arrows, PgUp/PgDn | SATISFIED | All four key combos handled in handle_key(); scroll_down()/scroll_up() with saturating_add/sub and max_scroll() clamping |
| NAV-06 | 02-01, 02-03 | User lands on index.md as the entry point | SATISFIED | vault::load_document(&app_config.vault_path, "index.md") called unconditionally on startup |
| NAV-07 | 02-03 | User sees graceful error page when a linked file is not found | SATISFIED | draw_error_screen() renders BBS-style centered error box with red border, "*** SYSTEM ERROR ***" header, path in Yellow, hint in DarkGray |
| NAV-08 | 02-03 | User sees keyboard hints in status bar | SATISFIED | draw_status_bar() shows q:Quit j/k:Scroll PgUp/PgDn:Page (non-login) or Ctrl+C×2:Quit j/k:Scroll PgUp/PgDn:Page (login shell) in reverse video |
| NAV-09 | 02-03 | App handles terminal resize without breaking layout | SATISFIED | Event::Resize(w, _h) in event loop calls handle_resize(w) which re-renders markdown at new width and clamps scroll offset |
All 15 required requirement IDs accounted for. No orphaned requirements.
REQUIREMENTS.md traceability table marks REND-03, REND-10, NAV-05, NAV-06, NAV-07, NAV-08, NAV-09 as "Complete" and REND-01, REND-02, REND-04, REND-05, REND-06, REND-07, REND-08, REND-09 as "Pending" — the checkbox status in REQUIREMENTS.md is inconsistent with actual implementation, but the traceability table correctly maps all 15 IDs to Phase 2. The code implements all 15.
Anti-Patterns Found
| File | Line | Pattern | Severity | Impact |
|---|---|---|---|---|
src/renderer.rs |
356-358 | placeholder string |
Info | Intentional: the [IMAGE: alt text] placeholder is the correct implementation of REND-07, not a stub |
No blocker or warning anti-patterns found. cargo build output: 1 pre-existing warning (init_logging dead_code in signals.rs — not introduced by Phase 2), zero errors.
Human Verification Required
The following behaviors require a running terminal session to confirm visually:
1. Markdown Rendering Visual Quality
Test: Create a vault with index.md containing H1-H6 headings, bold/italic text, a fenced code block with rust language tag, an unordered list, a blockquote, a horizontal rule, an image reference, and a GFM table. Run cargo run.
Expected: Each element renders with distinct CGA colors; H1 has a ═ decorator, H2 has a ─ decorator; code block has ╭─ rust ─╮ top border with syntax-highlighted content; table has ┌┬┐ grid; blockquote has yellow │ left border.
Why human: Visual styling and color accuracy cannot be verified without a running terminal.
2. Scrolling Feel
Test: Load a document longer than the terminal height. Press j, k, PgDn, PgUp, and arrow keys.
Expected: Content scrolls smoothly; scroll stops at top and bottom of document without overshooting.
Why human: max_scroll() clamping logic is verified in code, but the user experience of scrolling (responsiveness, no flicker) requires a live terminal.
3. Status Bar Display
Test: Observe the bottom line of the terminal.
Expected: Filename appears left-aligned, keyboard hints right-aligned, entire bar is reverse-video (text and background inverted). Quit prompt replaces hints when Ctrl+C is pressed once.
Why human: Modifier::REVERSED rendering depends on terminal emulator support; visual verification required.
4. Missing index.md Error Screen
Test: Configure vault_path to a directory without index.md. Run cargo run.
Expected: Centered box with red border, *** SYSTEM ERROR *** in bright red, vault directory path in yellow, Create index.md to begin. hint in dark gray.
Why human: Visual centering calculation and color rendering require live terminal.
5. Terminal Resize Re-render
Test: While running with a wide terminal, resize the terminal window to half width. Expected: Horizontal rules shrink to new width; code block borders reflow; no crash; scroll offset clamped if needed. Why human: Resize event behavior requires interactive session.
Commits Verified
All commit hashes documented in SUMMARYs confirmed present in git log:
| Hash | Plan | Description |
|---|---|---|
7622d41 |
02-01 Task 1 | feat(02-01): add Phase 2 deps and vault file-loading module |
8d45a7c |
02-01 Task 2 | feat(02-01): add syntax highlighter module with CGA color mapping |
9e6f79c |
02-02 Task 1 | feat(02-02): build core markdown renderer with inline and block elements |
8690d2a |
02-02 Task 2 | feat(02-02): add code block borders with syntax highlighting and GFM table grid |
9cdfc6b |
02-03 Task 1 | feat(02-03): rework app.rs with document display, scrolling, status bar, error screen |
ddf9ebc |
02-03 Task 2 | feat(02-03): wire main.rs with highlighter init, vault loading, and renderer |
Gaps Summary
No gaps. All 17 must-have truths are verified against the actual codebase. All 15 requirement IDs are implemented. Build is clean. Key links are wired. No stub patterns detected.
Verified: 2026-02-28T21:45:00Z Verifier: Claude (gsd-verifier)